While I really liked the
movie I loved the book. It has the same
sub-plots as the movie but, as with any book, it has the opportunity to provide
a lot more detail and back story than the limited time a movie is allowed. All the major characters and most of the
minor ones find their way from the book into the movie. There were some minor plot changes and major
ending changes which I think the movie actually did a better job with than the
book.
The book though is a
treasure. I usually storm through a
book, skimming large portions to get to the main plot points. This book made me slow way down and for a
very good reason. Mitchell does a superb
job of providing depth and detail in every sentence. His characters come alive even though he
exposes them each in the wildly different formats of his varied sub-plots. I noticed the same thing recently reading
Gatsby. Mitchell has the potential to rank
up there with Fitzgerald.
The book is also a more
coherent read than the movie which mixed up the stories into an almost dizzying
swath jumping back and forth in time.
Both formats worked, again a product of the visual versus written
medium. I am once again astounded that
the filmmakers took this book on and am so glad they did. I can’t wait to discuss it with my daughter
again.
Speaking of my
daughter. The pictures are starting to
appear from the wedding of one of her best friends who has been chronicled in
this blog before. She’s my daughter’s former
roommate and this past weekend she tied the knot with the dancing star from my
daughter’s wedding. It looked like a
very hip, New York
style wedding but anytime you get the curbside gals together – fun will blossom
and permeate the entire atmosphere.
Congrats to the newlyweds!
Daughter and Globetrotting Son in Law Together for the Wedding |
The Happy Couple - One Very Lucky Young Man |
On a decidedly more somber
note – I received the following message from an Army buddy about a true hero –
someone who deserves a hell of a lot more attention and status than today’s
preening celebrities:
“You're a 19 year old kid. You're
critically wounded and dying in the jungle somewhere in the Central Highlands
of Viet Nam .
It's November 11, 1967. LZ X-ray. Your unit is outnumbered 8-1 and the enemy
fire is so intense from 100 yards away, that your CO (commanding officer) has
ordered the MedEvac helicopters to stop coming in. You're lying there,
listening to the enemy machine guns and you know you're not getting out. Your
family is half way around the world, 12,000 miles away, and you'll never see
them again. As the world starts to fade in and out, you know this is the day. Then
- over the machine gun noise - you faintly hear that sound of a
helicopter. You look up to see a Huey
coming in. But… It doesn't seem real because no MedEvac markings are on it. Captain
Ed Freeman is coming in for you. He's not MedEvac so it's not his job, but he
heard the radio call and decided he's flying his Huey down into the machine gun
fire anyway. Even after the MedEvacs
were ordered not to come. He's coming anyway.
And he drops it in and sits there in the machine gun fire, as they load
3 of you at a time on board. Then he flies you up and out through the gunfire
to the doctors and nurses and safety. And, he kept coming back!! 13 more times!! Until all
the wounded were out. No one knew until the mission was over that the
Captain had been hit 4 times in the legs and left arm. He took 29 of you and
your buddies out that day. Some would not have made it without the Captain and
his Huey. Medal of Honor Recipient, Captain Ed Freeman,
United States Army, died at the age of 70, in Boise , Idaho .
May God Bless and Rest His Soul.”
R.I.P. to a True Celebrity |
The exquisite bravery and honor displayed at the Battle for LZ X-Ray was chronicled in the excellent
book and movie – We Were Soldiers Once and Young.
Excited to discuss this weekend, Dad!
ReplyDelete